I do know there’s a tremendous amount to be gained by following a recipe to the letter … and then there is old fashioned “just have to make do”. I truly enjoy doing a recipe to be authentic. I also realize there are those times when it just isn’t meant to be … and this was one of them. Perhaps in the long run there is as much to be gained/learned from one way as the other.
Aparna (My Diverse Kitchen) very kindly invited us round her kitchen table this month to bring us a love story and a bread to fall in love with. She hoped to find a different bread, a challenging bread and a fun bread for us to bake. In my book she succeeded in spades. This is one of those breads I think you will find an endless number of ways to top it and I think it can be one of those stellar breads to use for special times. These breads are cracker like – they benefit immensely by crisping them up in the oven before serving. We’ve been invited to friends for Thanksgiving and I’m thinking these might be a perfect little bite to take with a smoked salmon spread.
Now … about that mawa … did you really hear me whaling … yes, that was me. No stove top, no hot plate. I tried the slow cooker … didn’t taste bad but it was so dark and all the babes were getting this lovely light yellow creamy color, I just couldn’t use what I took out of the crock pot. The substitution that seemed most likely was ricotta cheese.
You will see I used all whole grain/wheat in this recipe. The only white I used was when I dusted the rolled out dough and put on the ghee. Yeah, I even added my trademark ground flax seed meal. I used all the liquid called for … and I changed the water to milk. Why? Why milk? I don’t really have an answer, it just seemed the right thing to do. Because I used the whole grain and the flax, I mixed this dough up the night before to allow all the whole grain to hydrate with the idea this would keep the bread from being dry.
These create a wonderfully buttery aroma coming out of the oven. Easily a welcome aroma around holidays.
Dhakai Bakharkhani/ Baqeerkhani (Crisp Flatbreads from Dhaka, Bangladesh)
Recipe By: Aprana: Adapted from Honest Cooking ( )
For the mawa/ khoya:
1 litre full fat milk (2% will also do) – makes approximately 3/4 to 1 cup mava
For the Bakharkhani:
170 grams white whole wheat flour, (plus a little more for rolling it out the dough)
135 grams sprouted whole wheat flour
1/4 cup mawa, substituted ricotta cheese
1/4 cup ghee* (plus a little more for spreading on the dough while rolling it out)
1/4 teaspoon salt
10 grams brown sugar
2/3 cups skim milk (a little less or more if needed)
Sesame seeds, to sprinkle (optional)
walnuts , chopped
1. *ghee is nothing but clarified butter and should be available readymade in Indian stores. It is quite easy to make your own at home. Since you are making the effort you can make a little extra and store the rest for later use. Ghee can be stored at room temperature and keeps for a while.
Melt 500gm of unsalted butter and let it cook until the milk solids in the butter start turning golden brown (do not burn them) and the liquid fat is a golden color. You should get a rich aroma from it.
Let it cool to room temperature and then decant or strain the golden liquid into an airtight jar.
I managed this very easily (carefully monitored) in the microwave.
2. Make the mawa/ khoya:
Pour the milk into a heavy bottomed saucepan, preferably a non-stick one. Bring the milk to a boil, stirring it on and off, making sure it doesn’t stick to the bottom.
Turn down the heat to medium and keep cooking the milk until reduces to about a quarter of its original volume. This should take about an hour to an hour and a half. The important thing during this process is to watch the milk and stir it frequently to make sure it doesn’t stick to the sides or bottom of the pan and get burnt. The danger of this happening increases as the milk reduces and gets thicker.
Once the milk it has reduced to about one fourth, 1/4 quantity, lower the heat to low and let cook for a little while longer. Keep stirring regularly, until the milk solids (mawa) take on a lumpy appearance. There should be no visible liquid left in the pan, but the mawa should be a bit moist and not stick to the sides of the pan.
Let it cool. Once it has cooled, it should still be a little moist but you should be able to crumble it.
Make it in a crock pot:
1. On stove top or in a microwave oven heat milk between 180ºF to 190ºF.
2. While heating milk, put about 2 quarts of water in the slow cooker, cover with lid and turn it high for 20 minutes. You are basically preheating the the insert, so that it will not crack.
3. When the milk has reached, the 180ºF, drain the water out of the slow cooker insert. Transfer the hot milk to the insert.
4. Cover the insert with the lid, leaving about 1″ crack. This will allow the steam to escape during evaporation. Turn the cooker to ‘Low’
5. Every 30 minutes or so, stir scraping the sides and the bottom. In about three hours, you should have about 5 cups of Chikna Khoya.
3. Making the Bhakarkhani:
In a large bowl, put the flour, salt and sugar into a large bowl. Crumble the mawa into it and mix in. Then add the ghee and use your fingers to rub it into the flour. Add the water, a little at a time, and knead well until you have a smooth and elastic dough that can be rolled out very thin.
Please see this video to get an idea of how the dough is rolled out, layered with ghee and flour and folded. The language in the video is Bangla but the visual is quite descriptive. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eyiOLuJywHQ )
4. Cover the bowl with cling wrap or a damp kitchen towel to prevent it from drying. Let it rest for about 30 minutes to an hour. Then lightly coat the dough and then let it rest for another 10 to 15 minutes.
Preheat oven to 170C (325F).
5. Lightly coat your rolling pin and board (or your working surface) with some ghee.
Now divide the dough into two portions, working with one portion at a time. Roll out one portion of the dough as thin as possible into a rectangle, without adding any flour. It should be thin enough for you to see your work surface through the rolled out dough!
Brush some ghee (not too much) all over the surface of the rolled out dough with your fingers. Sprinkle some flour evenly over this, enough so that the ghee is absorbed when spread out. The flour layer should be thin. Brush some more ghee, again, over this and then sprinkle some flour over this like previously.
Fold the dough into half and once again repeat the process of brushing the ghee and sprinkling the flour over this twice, as before. Fold the dough for the second time (see the video) and repeat the brushing with ghee and flouring, twice.
Now roll up the dough into a long cylinder and let it rest for about 10 minutes.
6. Pinch off lemon sized balls and roll each one into a small, round flatbread. Sprinkle sesame seeds (optional) and lightly press into the dough. Make three cuts on each flatbread using a knife. Place on parchment lined baking sheets and bake for about 20 to 25 minutes or until they’re light brown on top. Do not over bake.
Let them cool and serve with coffee or tea.
So you’ve read the recipe and you’re shaking your head thinking “that’s beyond me. I tell you it’s not. Really, go for the ricotta like I did if you want to really cheat – but all reports are if you have a stove top and use your widest pan to create the largest evaporative surface area for the mawa. Watch the rolling out video – I watched it once and then just winged it. This will work for you and you’ll have a wonderful rich, crisp flatbread under your belt, your kitchen will smell devine and somebody may even love you as much as Aga Bakar loved his mate (you did read the love story on Aprana’s blog didn’t you?). Well, go read it and bake this bread.
November 17, 2014 at 3:22 pm
You see, Tanna? This is what I LOVE about sharing a specific recipe with a group! I’m so so happy that you made so many significant changes and yet still ended up with something quite similar to what we made. (I snuck some whole wheat flour in as well. I’m going to pretend that it was because I was mimicking hand-milled flour.)
How brilliant to substitute with ricotta cheese. While it’s not quite the same because of the acid added to create it, it’s not that far off either.
You’re right! These would be great with smoked salmon spread!
November 18, 2014 at 2:32 am
Well…. you made it sound doable LOL. Smoked salmon and maybe a Sauterne? I’ve one in the cave…
Pingback: Bread Baking Babes bake Bakharkhani, and a love story - Thyme for Cooking, Blog
November 18, 2014 at 5:53 am
Good to know they’re doable with whole wheat too! Do I see right in that last picture you paired salmon with strawberry? Is that really good? Smoked salmonspread… I say YES! Somehow it was more a savory companion (soup, stew) than with tea to me
November 24, 2014 at 8:13 am
Yes, Lien we enjoyed the fresh strawberries and the salmon, might not be for every one.
November 23, 2014 at 8:50 am
What a sport! You made this recipe work for you without giving up. The whole grain and flax sounds really good. I really enjoyed this one.
November 24, 2014 at 8:12 am
We loved the flaky crisp with these.